โป๏ธ Chapter 07 ยท Topic 05 ยท Sustainable Development
Carbon Credits & Carbon Trading
Carbon credits, cap-and-trade, carbon tax, carbon offset, CDM, Joint Implementation, Article 6 of Paris Agreement, India’s Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS) โ complete UPSC & PSC notes.
๐จ What is a Carbon Credit?
- A carbon credit = a permit that allows the holder to emit one tonne of COโ (or equivalent GHG)
- Carbon credits are tradeable โ companies that emit less than their allowance can sell surplus credits to companies that emit more
- The goal: create a financial incentive to reduce emissions โ it becomes cheaper to reduce emissions than to buy credits
- 1 carbon credit = 1 tonne of COโ equivalent (COโe) reduced, avoided, or removed
- Two main types of carbon markets:
- Compliance markets โ mandatory; regulated by governments; companies must participate (e.g., EU ETS)
- Voluntary markets โ companies voluntarily buy credits to offset their emissions; not legally required
๐ญ Cap-and-Trade System
- Government sets a cap (limit) on total GHG emissions from covered sectors
- Companies receive or buy emission allowances up to the cap
- Companies that emit less than their allowance can sell surplus allowances
- Companies that emit more must buy additional allowances or face penalties
- The cap is gradually reduced over time โ total emissions decline
- EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) โ world’s largest carbon market; launched 2005; covers power, industry, aviation
- Other ETS: California, China (world’s largest by volume), South Korea, New Zealand
โญ Carbon Tax vs Cap-and-Trade:
Carbon tax = sets a price on carbon; companies pay a fixed tax per tonne of COโ emitted; quantity of emissions uncertain. Simple, predictable, easy to administer.
Cap-and-trade = sets a quantity limit; price of carbon fluctuates with market; total emissions certain. More complex but guarantees emission reductions.
Both are market-based instruments (MBIs) that put a price on carbon to incentivise emission reductions.
Carbon tax = sets a price on carbon; companies pay a fixed tax per tonne of COโ emitted; quantity of emissions uncertain. Simple, predictable, easy to administer.
Cap-and-trade = sets a quantity limit; price of carbon fluctuates with market; total emissions certain. More complex but guarantees emission reductions.
Both are market-based instruments (MBIs) that put a price on carbon to incentivise emission reductions.
๐ Kyoto Protocol Mechanisms
| Mechanism | Description | Parties Involved |
|---|---|---|
| Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) | Developed country funds emission reduction project in developing country; earns Certified Emission Reductions (CERs) | Annex I country + Non-Annex I country |
| Joint Implementation (JI) | Annex I country funds project in another Annex I country (economies in transition); earns Emission Reduction Units (ERUs) | Two Annex I countries |
| Emissions Trading (ET) | Annex I countries trade Assigned Amount Units (AAUs) โ their emission allowances | Between Annex I countries |
๐ CDM & India: India was one of the top CDM host countries globally. Indian CDM projects included: wind energy, solar energy, biomass energy, energy efficiency, waste management, and afforestation. India earned millions of CERs (Certified Emission Reductions). CDM projects in India were registered with the UNFCCC CDM Executive Board. CDM has been replaced by Article 6 mechanisms under the Paris Agreement.
๐ Article 6 of Paris Agreement
- Article 6 establishes the framework for international carbon markets under the Paris Agreement (replacing Kyoto mechanisms)
- Article 6.2 โ bilateral/multilateral cooperative approaches; countries can transfer emission reductions (Internationally Transferred Mitigation Outcomes โ ITMOs)
- Article 6.4 โ new centralised UN carbon market mechanism (successor to CDM); “Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism”
- Article 6.8 โ non-market approaches (e.g., capacity building, technology transfer)
- Rules for Article 6 were finalised at COP26 (Glasgow, 2021) after years of negotiations
- Key safeguard: corresponding adjustment โ when a country sells carbon credits, it must adjust its own NDC accounting to avoid double-counting
๐ฎ๐ณ India’s Carbon Market โ CCTS
- India is developing its Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS) under the Energy Conservation (Amendment) Act, 2022
- The Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) is the nodal agency
- CCTS will cover energy-intensive industries; companies that reduce emissions below targets earn carbon credits; those above targets must buy credits
- India’s existing Perform, Achieve and Trade (PAT) scheme โ energy efficiency trading for designated consumers (DCs) in energy-intensive sectors; earns Energy Saving Certificates (ESCerts)
- India’s Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs) โ tradeable certificates for renewable energy generation; promote renewable energy in states with poor renewable potential
โญ Carbon Offset vs Carbon Credit: A carbon credit is a permit to emit (used in compliance markets). A carbon offset is a reduction in emissions elsewhere to compensate for emissions at source (used in voluntary markets). Examples of offsets: planting trees (carbon sequestration), funding renewable energy projects, methane capture from landfills. Offsets are controversial โ critics argue they allow companies to continue polluting rather than reducing emissions at source.
๐ณ REDD+ โ Forests & Carbon
- REDD+ = Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (+ conservation, sustainable management, enhancement of forest carbon stocks)
- A UNFCCC mechanism that provides financial incentives to developing countries to protect forests
- Countries earn carbon credits for reducing deforestation below a reference level
- India has significant REDD+ potential โ large forest cover; Green India Mission
- Challenges: measuring forest carbon accurately; ensuring permanence; addressing leakage (deforestation shifting elsewhere)
โ Revision Checklist โ Carbon Credits & Trading
โ
Carbon credit = permit to emit 1 tonne COโe; tradeable
โ Compliance markets = mandatory (EU ETS); Voluntary markets = optional
โ Cap-and-trade = government sets emission cap; companies trade allowances
โ EU ETS = world’s largest carbon market = launched 2005
โ Carbon tax = fixed price per tonne COโ; cap-and-trade = quantity fixed, price varies
โ CDM = developed country funds project in developing country = earns CERs
โ JI = between two Annex I countries = earns ERUs
โ India = top CDM host country; wind, solar, biomass projects
โ Article 6 Paris Agreement = new carbon market framework = rules finalised COP26
โ Corresponding adjustment = prevents double-counting of carbon credits
โ India’s CCTS = Carbon Credit Trading Scheme = Energy Conservation Act 2022
โ PAT scheme = energy efficiency trading = ESCerts = BEE
โ RECs = Renewable Energy Certificates = promote renewable energy
โ REDD+ = reduce deforestation = financial incentives for forest protection
โ Carbon offset = emission reduction elsewhere to compensate for emissions at source
โ Compliance markets = mandatory (EU ETS); Voluntary markets = optional
โ Cap-and-trade = government sets emission cap; companies trade allowances
โ EU ETS = world’s largest carbon market = launched 2005
โ Carbon tax = fixed price per tonne COโ; cap-and-trade = quantity fixed, price varies
โ CDM = developed country funds project in developing country = earns CERs
โ JI = between two Annex I countries = earns ERUs
โ India = top CDM host country; wind, solar, biomass projects
โ Article 6 Paris Agreement = new carbon market framework = rules finalised COP26
โ Corresponding adjustment = prevents double-counting of carbon credits
โ India’s CCTS = Carbon Credit Trading Scheme = Energy Conservation Act 2022
โ PAT scheme = energy efficiency trading = ESCerts = BEE
โ RECs = Renewable Energy Certificates = promote renewable energy
โ REDD+ = reduce deforestation = financial incentives for forest protection
โ Carbon offset = emission reduction elsewhere to compensate for emissions at source